What are the differences between the book and movie that make it so. How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen king. The shining, one of stanley kubricks latest films, has been for years the subject of a thousand theories, conspiracies and debates. List of differences between the book and film the shining wiki. Jun 05, 2015 stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. As you look at just how much is different from the shining book compared to the movie, some of kubricks changes seem almost like purposeful. Jack, in a moment of sanity tells danny and wendy to get out and tries to relieve the pressure in the boiler. Jun 07, 2015 whats different between the shining book and movie. Stephen king has also written doctor sleep which is. Adapting a book into a movie inevitably means making tough. In the book in the movie the motivation of the ghosts is to possess jack torrance to get him to kill danny. Duvalls wendy torrance was gentle, submissive, nervous, and passive the complete opposite of the wendy from the shining book. The movie was better than the book, ergo, the movie is better than the tv special.
Essay the shining by stephen king the shining is a novel written by stephen king in 1977 and a horror movie directed by stanley kubrick in 1980. How doctor sleep is different from stephen kings book. Jun 26, 2018 stephen kings book the shining and stanley kubricks corresponding adaptation are both staples of the horror genre, but theyre also very different beasts. When stanley kubrick directed his film adaptation of the shining, author stephen king. Stanley kubrick took a lot of liberties with the story and characters from stephen kings the shining. How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen kings novel related. Facebook messenger click the button below and wait for a message. Whats different between the shining book and movie.
The film version made big changes to the character of jack overall, and subsequently, many elements of the story were completely modified to better represent the character the picture was working with. Stanley kubrick made quite a few changes to the original stephen king storyline, keeping only the bare bones plot line of the book. The film is based on stephen kings 1977 novel of the same name and stars jack nicholson, shelley duvall, scatman crothers, and danny lloyd. Thats what it looks like to an outsider, and thats the story kubrick wanted to tell. Home essay samples entertainment movie analysis the shining. The shining 1977 is stephen kings third novel, and according to wikipedia, the one that established him as a popular author. Stephen kings book the shining and stanley kubricks corresponding adaptation are both staples of the horror genre, but theyre also very different beasts. Taken from one of the first successful novels by stephen king, the film has voluntarily marked many substantial differences with the book, differences that have been the subject of several analyses by fans and. Why is the shining book better than the shining movie. Here are the major differences between the doctor sleep book and mike flanagans movie.
One of the biggest differences is that the wendy from the novel actually stands up to jack, whereas the film version is quiet and constantly looks afraid to even talk to her husband which is understandable given jacks personality in the film. The shining warner brothersgetty images stephen king doesnt think stanley kubrick told the story correctly. Few authors have been adapted as many times as king has, and it chapter two is far from the first king movie to deviate from his original ending. The shinings 1980 hedge maze chase is one of the most iconic endings in horror history. Heres the most thorough analysis of the differences between the 2 shinings that has ever been written. We all know that the stanley kubrick version of stephen kings book the shining is great, but there was also made for tv movie by the same name that came out few years ago. In the book, jack torrance went on a rampage with a croquet mallet, not an axe. It is terrorizing audiences, but what was left out from the book. Stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. When stanley kubrick directed his film adaptation of the shining, author stephen king hated it. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie.
A t book readings, stephen king sometimes tells a story about his only preproduction discussion for the 1980 film adaptation of the shining. Flanagans doctor sleep draws heavily on elements in the book version of the shining that. Differences between the shining book vs movie page 4. This is not an example of the work written by professional essay writers. But if youve read the book and watched the film, its pretty obvious stanley went in a very different direction with his interpretation of stephens story, which the writer wasnt too impressed with. In the movie the motivation of the ghosts is to possess jack torrance to get him to kill danny. The return to the overlook in the films third act is one of two major differences between the movie and its 20 source material, the other being dans ultimate fate. Stephen king wasnt a big fan of kubricks adaptation of his novel, the shining. The film version of the character spends a big part of the story on the verge of a breakdown, finally collapsing on the third act, while the books. Heres every difference between the shining book and the film. Movie november 6, 2015 november 6, 2015 mkwierzal alright, i know halloween time is over and yummy turkey time has begun, but i only just finished reading a horror classic and rewatching its movie adaptation, and the differences between the two are so striking i. In the film, one of the final shots is jack torrance having frozen to death in the maze, and the final shot is a close up of a picture that shows jack as the caretaker from all those years ago. Oct 01, 20 jack nicholson in the shining warner bros. Here are all the major differences between the book and film versions of the shining you need to know before seeing doctor sleep.
List of differences between the book and film is just that. King felt that kubrick had twisted his story, ignoring the inherent evil of the hotel, and generally. Movie, hell be taking a critical look at movie adaptations of horror novels. The death of another character is changed radically in the film. Stephen king has also written doctor sleep which is the shining book two. The eponymous shining plays a smaller role in the film than it does in the nov. List of differences between the book and film the shining.
The shining, the 1977 novel by stephen king, is widely considered one of the best horror novels ever written. We all know how intensely a book can be altered when revised from novel to film, but just what exactly gets lost in translation. What are the differences between the book and movie that. But if youve read the book and watched the film, its pretty obvious stanley went in a very different direction with his interpretation of stephens. Stanley kubrick made quite a few changes to the original stephen king storyline, keeping only the bare.
The movie is an exploration of the ways in which external space affects state. He starts off with not much personality, which is kind of saved up for later in the story when the house gets in his head and he becomes a clown. There are also differences in how the true knot go about kidnapping abra and how dan finds out about his and abras connection that are different between the movie and the book according to. Doctor sleep, the new stephen king movie from writer and director mike flanagan, tries to reconcile three essentially incompatible texts. What stanley kubrick got wrong about the shining stephen king has always disliked stanley kubricks film of the shining, and he has a point. However, kubricks adaptation of the shining deviates. The novel and movie tells a story about jack torrance, who becomes the offseason winter caretaker of the overlook hotel. What stanley kubrick got wrong about the shining salon. Kings book is a direct sequel to his 1977 novel the shining, and most definitely not a direct sequel to the 1980 film directed by stanley kubrick, which king notoriously hated.
Dec 11, 2015 we all know how intensely a book can be altered when revised from novel to film, but just what exactly gets lost in translation. If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and dont vote in the other threads. Danny has the shining as many others do around the world. Differences between the shining book vs movie page 1. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie subscribe. How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen. Stephen kings sequel to the shining changed a lot on its way to the big screen. The shining book vs movie all the differences between. The shining is a 1980 psychological horror film produced and directed by stanley kubrick and cowritten with novelist diane johnson. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie youtube. Watchmojo ranks the top differences between the shining book and movie.
Starring jack nicholson, shelly duvall and danny lloyd, the movie became an instant classic and is still hailed as one of the best horror. Stephen kings 1977 novel the shining, stanley kubrick. Nov 06, 2019 here are all the major differences between the book and film versions of the shining you need to know before seeing doctor sleep. More famously, the supernatural room in the book is room 217, but the stanley hotel, where the film was shot, asked that they use a nonexistent. Jun 26, 2012 if you take away the compelling emotional and moral commentary that fills the pages of the novel, the shining is the tale of three people wandering around a deserted building. With ghosts, visions and psychological horror, the shining by stephen king is a very good horror story, i would say one of his best, right up there with the likes of salems lot which is another sk novel that i recommend if you enjoy horror. And as the movie has been watched and rewatched people have found an enormous number of. Jack nicholson as jack torrance in the famous 1980 film. In the movie, wendy is meeker and much more under the influence of jacks more violent tendencies. Check out his first column below, exploring the shining. Was stephen king right to hate stanley kubricks shining. But if youve read the book and watched the film, its. The shining, the 1977 novel by stephen king, is widely considered one of.
Adapting a book into a movie inevitably means making tough decisions and cutting. The film is an adaptation of stephen kings 20 novel, which is itself a sequel to his 1977 classic the shining. It might be the ending that has the biggest difference between the book and the film. Oct 31, 2019 the shining warner brothersgetty images stephen king doesnt think stanley kubrick told the story correctly. The shining book vs movie all the differences between the. Movie november 6, 2015 november 6, 2015 mkwierzal alright, i know halloween time is over and yummy turkey time has begun, but i only just finished reading a horror classic and rewatching its movie adaptation, and the differences between the two are so striking i just have to talk about it. The shining book and movie differences, doctor sleep comes out this friday, the sequel to the iconic horror masterpiece the shining from director stanley kubrick featuring jack nicholson in one of the most grandiose wildeyed bugshit performances in history. We enter the mind of stephen king and give you all the scary stuff the movie s missing. A comprehensive list of all differences between the 1977 stephen king novel the shining and the stanley kubrick 1980 film adaptation. Book vs movie analysis this essay has been submitted by a student. Nov 08, 2019 stephen kings sequel to the shining changed a lot on its way to the big screen. Its a study of exactly what stanley kubrick changed from stephen kings novel as these alterations are essential for a thorough understanding of the movie. One of the biggest differences between the film and book versions of doctor sleep is the absence of references to kubricks version of the shining.
Heres every difference between the shining book and. Dec 21, 2007 differences between the novel and the movie. The adaptation is balancing act between kings books and stanley kubricks the shining. For me, the books version of benjamin braddock is a goodlooking sociopath almost on the patrick bateman scale, compared to the films uneasy. Stanley kubricks the shining was released in 1980, and since has been hailed as one of the greatest horror movies ever made. Dec 11, 2018 home essay samples entertainment movie analysis the shining. There are other slight differences in the shining, like how danny interacts with his imaginary. The tension felt when jack jack nicholson chases danny danny lloyd through the hotel grounds is incredible. The death is also nothing like jacks fate in the novelization of the shining, written by stephen king. Whats the difference between the shining book and movie. Movie how does stabley kubricks movie stack up against stephen kings book. Sacrificing himself so danny and wendy can escape the overlook hotel.
485 69 555 1170 532 124 513 740 703 457 1286 329 608 1355 1522 663 1213 394 596 165 419 896 548 696 242 920 1118 133 175 313 1399 611 130 1413 422 355